Mathematically Challenged Education Authority

What hope do the children have?

In the UK we suffer a very bad obsession with league tables in which the performance of every public body is graded (on an arbitrary scale) and compared against others – rarely in a like for like but that is another matter.

As you can imagine, schools bear the brunt of this. Parents are understandably determined to get their children the best education possible, often moving across the country to be in the catchment area of their chosen school. Most of this one-upmanship is derived from the school tables, helpfully published on the BBC website.

All the trust has to be placed in what ever body is responsible for collecting these numbers. Are they up to the task?

Idly surfing the web, I came upon this educational report on the BBC. It is the stats for an infants/primary school (ages 3 – 11) in Shrewsbury. All normal. Have a look at the stats and it seems like its a reasonably good school – it performs above the average for its educational authority, which is also above the average nationally.

Then have a look at this:

PERFORMANCE
37 eligible, 18.9% of whom had special educational needs

At first glance it seems normal and slightly low compared to some schools.

Then look at the numbers.

18.9% of 37 is 6.993.

This means that 6.993 students have special educational needs. How is that possible? Is this just a rounding problem? No, because 7 pupils would be 19% in any normal formulation.

Either the organisation who collates the stats is mathematically challenged, or they have massaged the numbers to make it look lower than it is (and are ethically challenged).

Whichever it is, how much faith can you have in this system?


Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property WP_Term::$cat_ID is deprecated in /homepages/34/d43362328/htdocs/ydontu/blog/wp-includes/category.php on line 378

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property WP_Term::$category_count is deprecated in /homepages/34/d43362328/htdocs/ydontu/blog/wp-includes/category.php on line 379

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property WP_Term::$category_description is deprecated in /homepages/34/d43362328/htdocs/ydontu/blog/wp-includes/category.php on line 380

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property WP_Term::$cat_name is deprecated in /homepages/34/d43362328/htdocs/ydontu/blog/wp-includes/category.php on line 381

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property WP_Term::$category_nicename is deprecated in /homepages/34/d43362328/htdocs/ydontu/blog/wp-includes/category.php on line 382

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property WP_Term::$category_parent is deprecated in /homepages/34/d43362328/htdocs/ydontu/blog/wp-includes/category.php on line 383
This entry was posted in Society and tagged , , , , , , , , by ATGW. Bookmark the permalink.

About ATGW

Civil serpent.

Deprecated: ltrim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /homepages/34/d43362328/htdocs/ydontu/blog/wp-includes/wp-db.php on line 3030

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property WP_Query::$comments_by_type is deprecated in /homepages/34/d43362328/htdocs/ydontu/blog/wp-includes/comment-template.php on line 1525

3 thoughts on “Mathematically Challenged Education Authority

  1. To be fair, they’ve followed rounding rules quite correctly — 18.9189189…% rounds to 18.9%. But seriously, three significant figures from 37 people? Shouldn’t be using percentages at all at that level of accuracy.

    Discarding the meaningless digits at the end will make it impossible to rank the schools of course, but that should be a clue that you’re ranking things by statistical noise.

  2. Andrew – good point, however saying 19% would have made a lot more sense.

    I think the missing .007 is significant and this is really a school for spies….

Comments are closed.